Showing posts with label books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label books. Show all posts

Wednesday, 6 April 2011

Book Reviews: The Slap by Christos Tsiolkas and Room by Emma Donoghue







Jacyee Lee Dugard and is narrated by five-year-old Jack, who lives in a locked room (11ft x 11ft) with his Ma.  As far as Jack is concerned, the room is the whole world and outside is outer space.  He knows he cannot leave and he doesn’t want to as Room is a safe sanctuary for him, even when the sinister Old Nick visits in the night.  Jack cannot conceive of any people or indeed any matter outside of his four walls and has never spent a moment of his life away from his mother so it comes as a shock to him when she gradually starts to reveal that there is a world outside of Room and it is filled with boys and girls and dogs and families and beaches and parks.  A world which she once loved before Old Nick abducted her at age 19, forcing her to live as his prisoner and sex slave for 8 years, during the course of which she gave birth to Jack following a previous stillbirth. 

At first I was hesitant to read this book, concerned it would be too sensationalist and would both glorify and underestimate the suffering that women like those mentioned above have experienced.  Instead I found a story which despite its bleak setting, offered a tale of maternal love and a boy trying to find his way in the world which transcends to tiny prison of Room.  In handing over the narration duties to Jack, Donoghue has avoided the temptation of long drawn out scenes of horror as this is not what Jack sees.  Hidden in the wardrobe each night he does not see Old Nick hurt his mother.  He knows they go to bed together but has no idea what this means.  The reader meanwhile reads his earnest account of counting the bed creaks until Nick makes his usual gasping sound with growing anguish for the two protagonists.  Similarly, Jack reports the fun games he plays with his Ma, such as exercising their voices by yelling at the skylight, flashing the lamp during the night or trying to guess the correct combination on the keypad entry system with a sense of glee whilst we, the reader, feel only admiration for the extremely courageous young mother who has gone to such extraordinary lengths to protect her son that he truly perceives no danger from their horrific and perilous situation.  Jack has no reason to guess that these games are a form of escape as he does not see Room as a place to be escaped from.  Tsiolkas could certainly learn a lot from Donoghue on the use of subtlety in writing. 

The second part of the book takes places outside of Room as Jack and his Ma adjust to the real world.  Donoghue has clearly done a lot of research into the physical and psychological effects of long term interment – especially in one who has never experienced an outside world to compare – and skilfully explores the difficulties encountered by Jack in the real world; from seemingly small details such as how to walk up and down stairs and problems posed by spatial awareness (how do you measure depth when you have only ever seen objects from a distance of 11ft max?) and sudden exposure to sunlight to bigger situations such as the sudden appearance of so many different people and the concept of shopping.  One thing which annoyed me about the book in the beginning was the over-emphasis on contemporary references (Jack enjoying dancing to Rihanna’s music videos on Room’s small tv set etc) but I can appreciate that this was a choice by the author to emphasise that such cruelty does happen and is probably still happening somewhere in this day and age.  Giving Jack and his Ma television was a master stroke as it allows the mother to keep up to date with the world but as a stranger looking in.  Upon release from Room, everyone seems to want to tell her about the black President but of course she already knows this.  In a sense, she has not been away from the world but the world has been kept away from her.  An of course, who in that situation would head straight to this facebook-thing they had heard about to find out exactly what happened to their friends and family members in the intervening years!

 Donoghue also uses Room to attack the notion of celebrity.  The scene where a group of sales assistants accost Jack for his autograph is particularly unsettling, as is the interview that Jack’s Ma gives to an Oprah-style host.  The whole world seems to want a piece of this pair without much consideration for the psychological effects they are experiencing.  Indeed the scrutiny and extent to which the world debates Ma’s parenting skills – was she correct to let Jack believe there was no world outside room and shield him from the dangers within? – leads her to doubt her own actions and outside of Room we see her pull away from Jack to his bewilderment as she starts to crave the life she has missed.  Again, seeing the action from Jack’s point of view means that we, re adult readers are left to draw conclusions and fill in the blanks as to what Ma may be thinking and there is a real collision of viewpoints when Jack insists on bringing items from Room into their new world as a means of familiarity and comfort whereas the same items represent to his Ma a reminder of the horror and struggles endured.

In much the same way as Roberto Begnini’s film “Life is Beautiful” is a study of fatherhood and the choices made to shield children from the ugliness of the world rather than a holocaust film, Room is not a book about abduction, imprisonment and rape.  Yes, it is disturbing in parts but never sensationalist in its approach.

Interestingly, both books rely heavily on the concept of breastfeeding beyond the normal (in the western world) child age to suggest the notion of irresponsible mothers and in both books, the act is depicted as rather sinister and inappropriate whether through Jack’s earnest discussion of which breast tastes creamier and constant lifting of his mother’s shirt to “have some” or the precocious Hugo arguing with his father over possession of Rosie’s “boobies” and Rosie herself deriving some sexual pleasure from Hugo’s suckling.  Breastfeeding in general continues to be a contentious issue even when it involves very young infants yet saying it may be distasteful is one of our society’s last taboos  (see Kathryn Blundell ‘s infamously controversial article and the vitriolic backlash on “creepy” breastfeeding) .  Indeed, I got into a heated debate with a close friend of mine (a mother) last year when I described how a woman had recently wandered around the tables of a fairly upmarket restaurant with her baby attached to her breast, much to the discomfort of other diners including my elderly father-in-law.  Now I am a supporter of breastfeeding but felt this woman was being deliberately provocative and it was not acceptable to carry out this action in this setting, in the same way as it would have been unacceptable to brush one’s hair at the table or display any normally private body part.  I certainly wouldn’t have had a problem with the breastfeeding being carried out at the mother’s own table with her party of friends.  My friend however went straight to the “you clearly hate children and mothers because you choose to be childfree” argument and proceeded to tell me how breastfeeding mothers are victimised and the baby had just as much right to have his dinner in the restaurant as the rest of us.  Yes, I countered, by the rest of us didn’t wander around tables of strangers whilst masticating.   But I digress and it is fair to say that most westerners do find the breastfeeding of a more advanced child quite distasteful.  In The Slap, Tsiolkas uses this to demonstrate Rosie’s new age approach to parenting and inability to say no to Hugo, instead pandering to his every whim and it is noted through the novel, at least when the central plot s remembered, that all characters, even Rosie’s husband, find this to be quite unsettling and unpleasant.  Without a counter argument from Rosie herself however, the reader is not given the opportunity to weigh up both sides of the issue and decide for him/herself.  Indeed the only concession to this is the aforementioned incident where Rosie seems to be enjoying the tug at her nipple just a little too much for comfort.  Again the unsubtle Tsiolkas hits us with the full force of the message that Rosie is an unfit mother who has turned Hugo into the monster he is.  By contrast Donoghue bravely dares to question the rights and wrongs of Jack’s suckling habit.  When this issue is raised during Ma’s interview she laughs in the concerned face of the sanctimonious presenter saying “In this whole story, that’s the shocking detail?”  This makes the reader question our own already formed opinions about not only the breastfeeding issue but our desensitisation to horrific ordeals such as abduction and rape through media saturation.  Instead we may choose to believe that Ma did the right thing in continuing to provide extra nutrition for her son beyond the meagre meals supplied by Old Nick or we may resolutely claim that this continued reliance on the breast may have damaged Jack’s social skills, perhaps irrevocably. 

It is obvious that I much preferred Room over The Slap but would be interested in others’ takes on the same books.  Do feel free to comment. 





Thursday, 3 March 2011

All About Me

Well hello there and welcome to my blog.  Have a seat, get comfortable and make yourself at home.  Hopefully this is the beginning of a wonderful friendship…

Let me tell you a bit about myself…

I am a Scottish (wah-hey!) woman, living in Edinburgh.  I’m really lucky to live in such a wonderful city and am sure I would have found my way here eventually, even if I hadn’t been born here.  I spent a brief period in my early twenties living and working abroad but having met the love of my life at a much earlier age than expected, I just couldn’t stay away from him and ended up returning to Edinburgh where we set up home together and eventually married in 2007. 

Blogging has been on my mind for a while.  In truth I’ve always harboured fantasies about having regular newspaper or magazine column – you know, those women that get paid for writing about their lives, loves and opinions on the world each week.  Given that I never pursued my dream of becoming either a travel writer or a food critic, I think it’s safe to say that neither the Guardian nor even the Scotsman is going to come knocking on my door for hilarious anecdotes or worldly views any time soon.  So blogging it is then!  But what to blog about?  There are a lot of experts out there in cyberspace who tell me that a blog must have a theme and should stick to one subject only.  Food blogs should be about food only, travel blogs likewise… What to choose? Who am I?  What do I do?

Food!  I love cooking and love eating even more.  I love watching cookery programmes, reading cookery books and in the spirit of the most passionate Masterchef contestant, I think about food constantly; always considering ingredients and recipes and I just love feeding friends and family and seeing that look on their face when I know I have hit a flavour combination just right!  I don’t want to just talk about food though.  Aside from anything else, I’ve usually halfway through dinner before I remember that I meant to take a photo of the impressive looking dish.  Plus, there are so many great food blogs out there.  Can I really compete with the likes of the wonderful Kavey Eats or Bon Apetit?

Travel!  I love going places and experiencing new things.  Well, going places and eating new things mainly…  Problem is, I haven’t travelled particularly extensively despite an ever growing must-go list.  We live on a bit of a budget; both get limited holidays from work and the clincher – my parents retired abroad.  Great decision for them.  Means that my choice of holiday destination is now somewhat limited though. 

I’m a film geek!  That’s right.  I’m not ashamed to admit it.  I love film and hubby and I are regularly greeted by staff at the local cinema as if we are old friends.  Yep, if the cinema were a bar in Boston, we would be Norm.  I love most films apart from really scary ones and rom coms.  Unfortunately this makes me somewhat of a pariah amongst fellow female friends.  Knowing how many films I watch, they are constantly trying to get my opinion on the latest Katherine Heigl/Matthew MCaughney/Kate Hudson love fest with the fabulous shoes and oh so cute ickle baby…  They don’t understand when I would rather talk about Almodovar’s vintage work or the sheer awesomeness of the latest comic book adaptation/Frank Miller effort etc.  So could I use my blog to review films?  Well, I may certainly enthuse about a movie I have loved but it’s a rather restrictive topic really, and I don’t want to turn my cinema trips into a chore by feeling that I have to blog after each and every film.

What about books?  I read a lot but not always new titles so not sure if there is an audience out there.  Also, I am already in a bookgroup so have space to share opinions on most of my reading material.

Music is good.  It makes, so a wise woman once said, the people come together.  Personally I listen to anything from hard rock to jazz with a bit of classical thrown in.  My tastes are eclectic and I love discovering new bands.  Can’t really see a blog being shaped around all this though…

Families feature heavily in a lot of blogs.  Personally OH and I are child free.  This is a conscious decision and contrary to popular belief, not one that was taken lightly.  A great deal of the thoughts swirling around my head on any given day tend to revolve around this issue and it is one I am constantly being asked to defend.  Yes, the childfree stance on life may be a regular feature of my blog but I don’t want to restrict my writings to just that.  There are already great blogs out there on this topic, such as Childfree Me and I don’t necessarily want to reinvent the wheel.  Neither do I want to set this out as the very essence of my being and the most interesting thing about me.  Above all I don’t want to attract haters.  I know you can’t please all the people all of the time but I feel us childfree women (never the men) attract a lot of bad press by those who don’t understand our views and I want this blog to be, well, a nicer place than that!

Life is an ongoing struggle.  OH and I live on a tight budget.  We would like nothing better than to move to a bigger, nicer house or even have the money to make our little flat look and feel a bit more homely but with ever rising prices, we are finding things tough.  It certainly doesn’t allow us to travel to the places we want to see or even be able to feast on the food we would like but we are doing our best to get by with the hand which we have been dealt.  Living on a budget could be a good blog theme – it would certainly encompass all the above aspects of our daily life – what we eat, how we travel frugally etc but then, that just brings me back to talking about general life with a bit of all the above elements thrown in from time to time.  Yes, a bit like those magazine columnists really! 

So I guess I’m going to be telling you more about my life and habitual musings.

So, now you have gotten to know a bit about me, I hope you will continue to read and interact with my rambling streams of thought.  Perhaps you will recognise bits of your own life, thirty-something or not. 

Welcome to the world of blog!